Pt. I: Edgar Rice Burroughs Rides The Rocket, A Short Life
January 3, 2012
Part I
Edgar Rice Burroughs Rides The Rocket
A Short Life
by
R.E. Prindle
Eddie was a ramblin’ gambling’ man. He was born in a pair of ramblin’ shoes and he always took the most desperate chances. When he succeeded he was spectacular but when he failed…oh, well.
Perhaps the biggest gamble he ever took was being born but then, as Eddie always said: to me to conceive is to act. Things started out well as he began his life as a little prince but would soon turn sour when he was eight and lost a confrontation with a twelve year old bully on a street corner on the way to school. That was a life changer; he’d gone from prince to pauper and worse was yet to come. But, hey, it’s all education, isn’t it now?
The next year he began a foot race with the plague which he would ultimately lose. But as with being born he was initially successful. In an effort to escape the epidemic he was transferred to an all girls school. Apparently this was a polite plague selecting only boys. So like young Achilles Eddie took his place among the young ladies.
Still pursued, as one imagines, he was put for safety in a Latin School, one imagines as a place the fever would never look for him and if it found him would never enter the abode of such objectionable learning. Still, a young man of means he owned both a pony and a bicycle. The pony he rode back and forth to school leaving it tethered outside while he soaked up the classical knowledge. The bicycle he rode for fun but tipped over banging his head against a curb. This left him dizzy for days perhaps contributing to his later character which was formed by a similar incident.
While secure at the Harvard Latin School of Chicago for a couple years, the plague was not to be baffled forever. Eddie took to his heels running as fast as he could way out across the Western Plains to Idaho to become a Jr. cowboy. No box tops necessary.
If this picture is any indication he was quite a dude. Look at those chaps! The rowels of those spurs were so big they dragged on the ground announcing his approach from some distance. It was not all bravado however as he did have quite a way with the horses. Eddie was quite happy on the ranch and he might have become a Sr. cowboy but fate put some itchin’ powder in Eddie’s ramblin’ shoes and he resumed his ramblin’ ways. Doing an intellectual about face he and his guitar showed up at a Harvard prep school called the Phillips Academy. It was soon discovered that he didn’t know how to play guitar and hadn’t even learned any good cowboy songs such as The Streets Of Laredo, The Chisholm Trail and other titles of that ilk. Didn’t even know how to sing, either.
This disappointed the faculty, as well as his low grades, so that they couldn’t bear Eddie’s presence. Thus he was told to put his ramblin’ shoes back on and git along.
As you can tell, by this time Eddie was accumulating a fair amount of educational experience though not of the academic sort. Still of tender years and still outdistancing the plague Eddie had to find another educational emporium to fill out his youthful years. His father, actually the agent of all this agitation, for some reason thinking him a delinquent, did what all fathers of delinquent kids do, he enrolled the lad in a military academy. Supposed to make you learn to stand up straight or something like that. Yep. If the plague showed up there they’d most likely make him stand at attention until he got tired of it.
After all this ramblin’ Eddie was becoming quite a character. In addition to performing some typical goofy stunts Ed was a star rider on the Equestrian team as well captaining the football team as a quarterback. Just to put in some good words for Eddie here and raise him in your estimation, Ed led the Michigan Military Academy Tigers, or whatever they were called, to a draw against the mighty University Of Michigan Wolverines. Always an odd sobriquet I thought and in a competition between a tiger and wolverine which would you bet on.
Now, this nearly miraculous feat did not go unnoticed. He so impressed the Wolverine coach that Ed was offered a full football ride at Ann Arbor. Well, you might say, that was really wonderful. Yes, it could have been. But the imp of the perverse was down in those ramblin’ shoes as well as the itching powder as Eddie turned the coach down. If the offer had come from Yale that would have been different, but UM? Eddie had his heart set on Yale, which his brothers had attended, and it was Yale or nothing. Yale was uninterested.
That was a positive life changing experience that Eddie missed but fate was cramming the next few years with a bunch more, some of them very memorable. Plus the plague was waiting for him just around the corner. That was going to be a stunner.
First up was one of those glorious once in a lifetime experiences that only succeeds if you’re at the right age. Eddie was and he had one glorious summer in the year of ‘93. The Chicago Columbian Exposition. The promoters couldn’t get it together to open in ‘92 which would have been that actual 400th anniversary year of the intrepid navigator’s voyage but the promoters were ready in ‘93. Eddie was seventeen and spent the summer of his life at the Expo grounds.
I’m going to have to try to set the Expo up for you because in its own way it was the highpoint of Western Civilization before and since. Western confidence just began to sort of evaporate after the fair was over.
II.
Eddie In Wonderland
The nineteenth century was quite something. It was the century of magnificent discoveries and achievement. Society chooses to diminish those wonderful scientists by derogatorily calling them Dead White Men while sneeringly dismissing them. Pardon me, if I’m sentimental but those were the guys that made the present possible and I can’t admire them too much. They’ll always be my revered ancestors to me and not Dead White Men. Down with negativity.
Technology and Science just exploded as scientific research opened new and very broad vistas to human view that never would have been opened without them. The machinery was incredible. The accumulated wonders were first put on display at London’s Crystal Palace Exhibition of 1851. Six million people wandered through. It was breathtaking as the world of tomorrow went on display.
The Centennial Exposition of 1876 in Philadelphia followed as an international competition began to form. Next came the 1889 fair in Paris for which the Eiffel Tower was created to form the triumphal arch through people entered the fair. Boy, there was an eye opener. Over a thousand feet tall, 300 steps up to the first level and 300 more up to the second. Tough act to follow but out there on the very edge of civilization existed the city to do it. Chicago. Chicago itself was considered exhibition enough. The Iron Chancellor, Bismarck himself, said that his only regret was dying without ever having seen that Chicago.
By 1893 the conditions for a perfect fair had formed. Steam safely delivered hordes from across the seas and steam brought them to Chicago in long lines of Pullman cars pulled by a mighty eight wheeler. The conditions were perfect and Chicago had the men of vision to realize the perfect fair- and how! And there were men to commemorate it as it deserved. H.H. Bancroft published a large size five volume set displaying its wonders in detail
The setting on Lake Michigan was spectacular; a one of a kind creation, never since replicated or even close to it. The Century Of Progress of 1933 was but a pale imitation. If you’ve read The Devil In The White City you know a fuller description than I’m going to give here. The White City, as the fair grounds were called, was a fairy land, life as it could be. It contrasted with the Black City, life as it was, of everyday Chicago. Industrialism was a recent phenomenon in the nineteenth century so that in the giddiness of creation such things as environmental concerns and labor relations had been neglected or at least not seen in their true importance. Everyday Chicago was a grim place; Eddie often makes unflattering remarks about his home town throughout his novels. It was smelly, smoky and dirty with huge slums not to mention institutionalized crime. They’ve shut down the stockyards but the criminal mentality remains.
The White City in contrast was a city as it could be and should. L. Frank Baum would later use it as the model for his Emerald City. As there was great labor unrest in Chicago at the time the labor force was critical. Those who signed on were quarantined to the site while work was in progress so as not to be corrupted by the labor dissidents. They threw up some of the most massive buildings in existence, practically overnight. They created pleasure gardens and a whole pleasure island. They had the midway of midways, in fact the term Midway was originated at the Expo. In competition with Paris’s Eiffel Tower the worlds’ first monster Ferris Wheel was brought into existence. While in the US the Wheel was turned into a carnival ride now many European capitols display huge four hundred foot Ferris Wheels next to their Houses of Parliament. No US city does; even the original Ferris Wheel was dismantled and has disappeared into some junkyard, perhaps having been converted into the steel beams of a skyscraper.
The Expo not only featured the technological and scientific triumphs of that fabulous nineteenth century but all the intellectual advances; Francis Galton the English psychologist displayed his achievements; Frederick Jackson Turner announced his seminal work on the disappearance of the frontier; The Congress of World Religions set up its tent over in the Black City to discuss how religion was to meet the challenge of science.
One of the first of the body builders, The Great Sandow, performed his strength stunts and flexed his muscles giving Eddie the germ for his seminal literary creation a few years hence.
Imitation Zuni Cliff Dwellings were created, a whole Dahomian village was thrown up, staffed with real Dahomians brought over for the fair. Eddie was influenced by these but he really enjoyed the peep show- forty beautiful women, count ‘em, forty, on display for your delectation.
Dozens of huge buildings from nearly every State and country, art works created an instant museum to rival the great museums of the world. Just outside the gates, too late to be included within, the fabulous Buffalo Bill’s Wild West. History portrayed while it was still in making out on the Western Plains. As incredible as it may seem among the performers was no less than Sitting Bull himself, the engineer of Custer’s defeat at his Last Stand. Amazing. It’s all show biz, folks.
The White City shot up out of the beach sands and chiggers, existed for a few months and then it was gone, burned to the grounds by the labor malcontents of the Black City. Fire is the devil’s best friend. Before it was gone Eddie and his fellows from the Michigan Military Academy marched into that Sacred City like so many Greeks at Troy, in pomp and circumstance. The troops of the MMA strutted in while the band played on. It filled Eddie’s heart with pride. Five years later, slightly inebriated, he and a friend would hire a band parading along behind it through the street of downtown Denver. Let’s just say the fair entrance was one of those thrills.
The summer of ‘93 was one for Eddie to remember. In a few years automobiles would begin to fill the streets of the Black City. In the White City of ‘93 Eddie beat them to the punch driving fair patrons around in his dad’s electric Morrison. The Morrison wasn’t much in the way of self propelled vehicles, being little more than a buckboard with benches on it, but, there was no horse in front of it and Ed was behind the wheel.
There was so much at the fair that a casual weekend visit was merely the smallest of sips, a week was a swallow, two weeks perhaps a draught. Nobody could take it in, nobody, but Ed that is. He had the full three months of that glorious summer to walk the walks, cross the bridges, stroll the romantic Wooded Island to the fabulous Japanese pavilion, gape and take it all in. You’ve got to remember that in those days before movies, TV, videos and color photography bound in convenient volumes no one, or at least very few, had ever seen such things. The fair was the prototype for all the Disney Lands and Worlds now dotting the planet.
What Ed might have missed he may have spotted in a newspaper account, rushing back to the grounds to take it in. Not everyone would know how to use what he saw and experienced, Ed did. Even if it was impossible for him to understand what he saw at the time, Eddie tucked it into the back of his mind from which it emerged in dribbles into his fiction over the thirty years of his writing career.
How lucky he was to pass the Summer of ‘93 in this wonderland. Truly a life changing experience. Not the only one coming up, Eddie had a lot more awaiting him in what he described as a boring life.
III.
Life Begins To Get Serious
First up was graduation from the MMA and the year he spent as a Geology instructor there. Then at the end of the year a depression seized Ed, probably caused by his failure to get an appointment to West Point. He joined the Army anyway leaving the MMA in the lurch while asking for the worst post in the Army’s jurisdiction. He got it. He was very lucky the Army wasn’t the French Foreign Legion or they might have assigned him to a post that made hell look a luxury resort, with no way out. The Army was more considerate, they sent him to Fort Grant in Arizona which was a few degrees cooler than hell although the accommodations were not much better.
The bad news was that Ed was in the Army finding this particular life changing experience, decidedly unpleasant; the good news was that Eddie really liked the desert and the Apaches. Zane Grey beat him to the punch writing about it but Eddie read Zane’s books assiduously. Both Arizona and Southern Utah, the border was disputed at that time, formed an irresistible attraction to him and he and Emma in their later years of marriage returned to it often. Even as Eddie was sadly contemplating divorcing this woman who had stuck with him through thick and thin, he retreated to the White Mountains Apache Reservation to ponder his situation. A deep respect for the Apaches was another consequence of his abbreviated tour of duty. Abbreviated because Ed developed what the Old Timers called a ‘tobacco heart’ and Ed had his dad use his influence to get him out. When the going got tough Eddie always took off running. He remembered that street corner in Chicago.
Well there he was, nearly twenty-five years old with no directions home although he did find his way back to Chicago, a story in itself, which I’m not going to tell here, but fragments of it can be found in The Return Of The Mucker. Ed knew how to use every scrap of his experience to advantage. For a couple years Ed hopped back and forth between Chicago and Idaho where his brothers were still running the ranch where Eddie earned those gigantic spurs.
It was on one of these trips he and an old Army buddy, a member of the Might Have Seen Better Days Club of that brief Army period, hired the band in Denver. It was also in Denver that Ed showed his gambling proclivities losing the money to cover the stretch from Denver to Idaho. As the baby brother, Big Brother Harry covered his act but Ed had set a dangerous precedent.
Part of the reason for Ed’s motation at this particular stage of his life was the maturing of his relationship with future wife Emma. As girls often do, she matured faster than Eddie and hearing her biological clock ticking was ready for the altar. Time was no longer on her side. Whether she could have ever rustled Ed out of bachelorhood is a topic for some rumination if she wasn’t at the same time being courted also by a rich handsome young fellow by the name of Frank Martin. Irish; always a red flag for Eddie who had some Irish blood of his own but considered himself a full blooded English type.
Rich and Irish. Franks’ dad was a big railroad magnate. Had his own private car to hitch at the back of the train. Well, to make a long story short Frank correctly discerned Ed’s intentions of wanting to remain a bachelor yet keep Emma on his string. Ed would go away but he wouldn’t stay away. Frank sat down and thought for a while, perhaps between breakfast and lunch, and thought he had devised a way to keep Eddie away…permanently.
It was a good plan and should have worked but it didn’t. Frank had his dad hook up the private car to a New York City bound train and then invited Ed along for the ride. Our Blithe Spirit got on the train without a qualm. One should never trust the other guy in matters concerning love or money. There are some guys who take the old saying everything’s fair in love and war quite seriously. Ed was to be given the coup de grace in Toronto on the way back. The boys went to the Toronto equivalent of Chicago’s Levee for a night’s entertainment. A couple thugs approached Ed flashing a black jack of sufficient weight and criminal dexterity to kill him but the coup and the grace separated. Ed was down and bloody but he survived. He promptly went back to Chicago and married Emma to keep her out of Frank’s hands. Now it was Frankie’s turn to cry.
We know he was a sore loser and if he didn’t stalk Ed he didn’t let him out of his sight either. Thirty-four years later when Ed and Emma parted Frank’s man Patchin was sent to LA to gloat over the divorce. Even when Eddie died, Frank had preceded him, Patchin sent a mocking letter to Ed’s son.
What I’m leading up to here is not even conjecture but just a bit of imagination, but since I know more than I’m telling, a possibility. As I pointed out for the last twenty years Ed had been dodging the plague; in 1901 he turned a corner and there he was face to face Mr. Typhoid Fever. Fever shook his hand and that was it. Eddie was down and almost out. It was a terrible bout but Ed did survive or else I might be writing about Zane Grey, a decidedly stuffy creature in whom I have no interest.
It was only a little over a year since Frank had been aced out of Emma. Definitely not long enough to cool off his hot Irish temper. A man who will attempt murder once will hold a long grudge and we know that Martin never stopped thinking of Emma and Ed. It may sound far fetched and may be it is, but as Ed caught the Typhus a year or so after snagging Emma I wouldn’t be surprised to learn that Frank Martin passed a stolen bacillus on to Ed in some way. Certainly he couldn’t have him assaulted again, an accident might have been difficult, so perhaps he introduced the disease into Ed’s food in some way. Just a suspicion.
Eddie didn’t bounce back to his feet but while he convalescing a very important book to him was issued which he devoured as it appealed to his romantic soul. He would read Owen Wister’s Virginian six or seven times by 1920. If one looks at in this way Ed made several attempts to escape Chicago until he finally succeeded in 1919. If one looks at it like that, as I say, Ed fled with Emma in 1903, 1913, 1916 and 1919.
I always look for a chain of events, the reason why. Wister’s The Virginian has a terrific reputation although it is one of those classics that leaves me cold. Wister was one of Teddy Roosevelt’s buddies. The book he wrote smells like a Gent roughing it in the wilds. Perhaps the appeal to Ed. On the one hand the novel deals with the Johnson County Range War in Wyoming of which Eddie was peripherally associated when he was an Idaho cowboy in ‘91. Several of the rebels who had killed men fled Wyoming while one or two went into hiding in Idaho. Ed apparently knew one of these desperadoes so The Virginian would have had a personal interest for him.
The love story of the book concerns a rough hewn poorly educated cowboy and a school teacher much above him who he woos and wins. They then wed while for their cowboy honeymoon the hero takes his new wife out into the picturesque mountains of Wyoming.
IV.
Buttons And Bows.
A Western ranch is just a branch
Of Nowhere Junction to me.
Give me that city
Where the living’s pretty
And the girls wear finery.
Ray Evans, Buttons and Bows
From Paleface of 1948 starring Bob Hope.
I haven’t read a study on Ed that gave any attention to understanding Emma or her history and yet she was a key figure in his success while after Ed divorced her his production declined in both quantity and quality. It would seem then that whatever drove him as a writer was connected to Emma
There were striking differences between Ed and Emma. Whereas Ed was shifted not only from school to school but from Illinois to Idaho to Massachusetts and finally to Michigan, Emma continued on at Brown School to graduation giving her a much more stable outlook on life. After graduation she studied voice in Chicago becoming familiar with the higher culture while Ed was much more familiar with the lower reaches of culture. Emma would often chide Ed for his lack of culture as he preferred boxing to opera and in later life would become a devotee of professional wrestling with all its vulgar connotations.
The Hulberts, Emma’s family, considered themselves as high class people and, indeed they were. Thus when Frank Martin came calling Emma’s father, Alvin was overjoyed finding Frank a perfect match for his daughter. Alvin quite frankly despised Eddie considering him a ne’er do well and young failure. There was certainly enough evidence to support his point of view. Before the marriage, in order to encourage Frank’s attentions to his daughter, Ed was forbidden the house. And yet Emma had her heart set on Ed and would have him. Apparently her affection never wavered although her opinion of her husband varied. As it would turn out Alvin’s view of the marriage was much more correct than Emma’s. She should have listened to her papa.
As a young girl and woman the Hulberts treated Emma to the best of everything. While her heart was set on Ed, it is obvious that she dated during all those years when Ed was not in Chicago. It is important to remember that Ed was from Chicago but his youth was spent elsewhere so that he was only faintly culturally of Chicago.
Emma was a clotheshorse. As the pictures show she was used to finery. Those are not only a lot of clothes she’s wearing but fairly expensive clothes. Clothes that Ed definitely could not provide her during the first decade or so of their marriage. When he did come into his money it was his pride that Emma could buy any clothes she wanted and he was happy to have her do so.
So, Ed, his head spinning from the Toronto bashing, and woozy from his fever attack, never particularly stable anyway, conceived the notion of taking Emma to the foothills of Idaho to reenact Wister’s novel. In 1903 then, Ed packed Emma and all their belongings to catch a train to Idaho riding baggage with Emma and their dog.
We have no record as yet of what Emma may have thought of this or whether she protested vehemently being overruled by Ed’s unreasoning passion. Of course between bashing, fever and excruciating headaches anyone might be excused erratic but innocent behavior.
Perhaps she objected using an analogous argument to Ray Evans’
My bones denounce the buckboard bounce
And the cactus hurts my toes
Let’s stay here where gals keep usin’
Those silks and satins and linen that shows
And I’m all yours in buttons and bows.
If she did use such an argument she was still in the baggage car with Ed and the dog.
I’m sure the trip was wildly romantic to Ed. His dad’s battery factory was on Madison, the hobo main stem so that I’m sure Ed had discussed the hobo life with them. His 1915 novel The Return Of The Mucker would celebrate the hobo life style as well as its successor The Oakdale Affair. So there they were, he, Emma and the dog in the baggage car like three hoboes.
Look at the picture of Emma in her finery standing in the boxcar. The look on her face echoes the lyric:
Don’t bury me in this prairie
Take me where the cement grows
Let’s go back to where I’ll keep on wearin’
Those frills and flowers and buttons and bows
Rings and things and buttons and bows.
I wonder if that was what was going through her mind.
Those long skirts didn’t work well out in the brambles, Emma didn’t have any other clothes, probably wouldn’t have worn pants if available, nor was Emma entranced with the one room balloon shack Ed threw up so their stay way out there was romantic to only one of them and of short duration.
Now comes an event painful to relate. Emma in her finery is way out there feeling miserable while Ed having removed wife and possessions to the romantic wilderness has only forty dollars in his pocket with no way to earn more. He was a rambler, he was a gambler.
Ed’s brother Harry was off in Parma so he and Emma went down to the station to catch a train to visit Harry. They had to put up for the night in what passed for a hotel room above the saloon. To this point in her life Emma had never even thought of roughing it and now she was learning all about it. To compound matters Eddie kissed her goodbye just like in Frankie and Johnny and went downstairs to find a poker game. His head must really have been hurting. They could have written the song Stagger Lee about him.
Well, he started with forty dollars thinking to inflate his stake to sixty or maybe eighty dollars but fate decreed that he come away with empty pockets. The possible reward wasn’t worth the risk. He had to have been playing with sharpies who took his cash and commiserated with his hard luck.
Let me illustrate how slick it can be. I was nineteen on the California Zephyr and two would be sharpers were trying entice me into a game of poker. They were really obvious and I wasn’t biting, I’d already dealt with sharpers aboard ship and come away cleaned. But, the railroad had an employee on board who must have been an amateur magician, he knew his cards. Dressed like a hick, walking and talking like one, he bustled up with his own deck of cards, invited me to stay, probably would have given me the best hands I’d ever seen because he meant me well, but I wasn’t really interested. Anyway he cleaned those two guys out in ten minutes and bustled off the way he came. They sat there stunned.
Now, I wasn’t present at the game Ed was in but I’d be totally amazed if those boys didn’t have a good laugh and dinner at Ed’s expense. Bad luck, good luck, Ed now stood at the bottom of the stairs swallowing hard, trying to figure out just how he was going to explain their dilemma to Emma. To be short about it, this was another one of those life changing experiences for Ed. No, sir, Ed didn’t have an explanation that Emma would accept. I mean, she could have married a millionaire and here she was in a wretched so-called hotel room a thousand miles from nowhere without a dime. Think about it. What was going through her mind?
Their relationship changed right there. It was a change that Ed would never be able to overcome; I’m sure it was the primary cause for the divorce thirty years later as Emma could never forget while Ed could never get over his shame. But, Ed hung in there for now. He recorded much of this period in his novel The Girl From Ferriss’s While a romanticized view of the years between 1900 and 1922 can be found in Marcia Of The Doorstep when Ed was again in hot water for overextending himself financially in LA.
I’m sure the railroads had a bitter taste for Ed after Frank Martin and Toronto. The memory of that private car shone in Ed’s mind like a diamond, but for now he took a job on the Oregon Shortline as a yard policeman in Salt Lake City. That is until Emma rebelled at taking in boarders ordering Ed to take her back to Chicago:
Let’s move back to that big town
Where they love a gal by the cut o’ her clothes
And I’ll stand out in buttons and bows.
Ed had a garage sale or whatever they called them back then actually selling Emma’s ornately carved marriage bed for a pittance. I’m sure that left a little scar too. Then, perhaps because Emma ragged him about riding baggage he bought a couple first class tickets back to the Black City which now appeared blacker than ever, I’m sure.
Ed was now a lost boy with responsibilities. The next seven years must have been a period of the blackest despair for him. He just couldn’t get his act together. He wandered from job to job. He landed a job at Sears, Roebuck that was a good job paying three thousand dollars a year. Not bad money in those days when unskilled labor worked six twelve hour days for from five hundred to seven-fifty a year. Ed’s prospects were good. He probably could have moved up into the five to ten thousand class in a few years. He showed up at his front door saying: Honey, I quit. Emma’s reaction wasn’t recorded but I’m sure it was voluble.
And then, of course, there were the pencil sharpeners. Ed never did sell one but he did sit down and write half of A Princess Of Mars. Who would have believed it? Munsey’s Magazine to who he had submitted it asked for the other half and gave him four hundred dollars to boot. Whether Ed and Emma sensed it or not they were on their way aboard the rocket, ready to ride.
We all hope for the success of our wildest dreams but few if any of us are prepared to manage the consequences of that success. It’s not as easy as it might seem. It’s sort of like the town bum spending a dollar for a lottery ticket and getting fifty million in return. If the bum thought he knew money before he is now introduced to the real thing.
For Ed who in his conception was born a prince, made a pauper, spending decades in disappointed expectations, now realized his destiny again. Upbraided by Emma for being a poor provider he was now in a position to provide her every desire, after taking care of his first, of course. The past weighed heavy on Eddie. The difficulties of his courtship and the shame of that gambling night in Idaho had to be rectified, reversed.
It couldn’t be, of course. One’s failures can only be recognized, accepted and lived with. But in a frenzy Ed thought that by repeating the private car incident and the disastrous trip to Idaho he could wash away the stains. Thus, having established a market for his goods, most especially with the creation of his ‘meal ticket’ Tarzan, Ed did an incredible thing. Remember he still had no money in the bank, betting entirely on the come.
As with Idaho he packed up all his goods including his useless second hand car, wife and by now three kids, bought five first class tickets to San Diego and made another attempt at fleeing Chicago. First class wasn’t the same as a private car but it was pretty close so Ed hopefully erased the shame of Frank Martin’s trip to New York City and back.
Once in San Diego, which stay lasted nine months, or long enough to be born again as the New Ed, he must have lived a princely existence going through most of the ten thousand he earned that year while returning to Chicago as broke as he had been when he and Emma boarded the train in Salt Lake City. So, he tried to eliminate his shame.
Once back in the Black City, having sold his production while in San Diego, he wrote some more, sold some more and made a seamless transition from the old Ed to the reincarnated Ed.
I would imagine that part of the plan was to get Tarzan published as a book and with that money establish himself as a man of means in his old home town. Move on up to the Gold Coast.
That would seem to be a very reasonable plan from our point of view but it was not that easy. Perhaps Tarzan, which is pure fantasy of the extravagant kind went well beyond publisher’ literary expectations. No one would touch it then, even though from our perspective the story was pure gold as, indeed, it turned out to be although not for Ed. Perhaps the novel appeared to the literary taste of Ed’s day as comic books did to literary lights in the forties and fifties of the last century, something to be burned and banned, hence Ed’s success was of the bastard sort.
He finally did get his novel published in book form in 1914 but he was stripped of most of the financial benefits as it went almost directly to reprint publishers; thus his royalties were more than halved and mere pittances of what they might have been. Still, by the time royalties began to come in Ed had created a backlog of Tarzan novels so that with current production one a year would be published for about ten years.
As the profit motive didn’t seem to be activating his publisher, the Chicago firm of McClurg’s, Ed was reduced to pleading with them to print at least twenty to thirty thousand copies before a novel was sent to the reprint house. It seems incomprehensible that McClurg’s wouldn’t do so on their own but they obstinately refused to make money for themselves and hence for Ed.
Well, the records, as I’ve been told, have been destroyed so what’s to be said. Once again I suspect outside interference. McClurg’s was an Irish house; Frank Martin was Irish. McClurg’s a was semi-public company open to investors one assumes; Frank Martin had money to invest. Until a better explanation is provided I have to believe something along those lines was happening.
But, if Eddie could have lived long enough the wonders he would have seen. At one hundred he would have been a very rich man. Those successful intellectual properties just keep gaining in value. Better than stamp collecting.
While Ed appears to have been stymied at the publishing end, that enterprise was old hat, the new wonder of the authorial imagination was movies. The Big Money, to quote John Dos Passos, Thus to some extent the movies made up for what Ed was being cheated out of in publishing. The first film production of Tarzan was the industries first million grosser. Thus when Ed successfully fled Chicago in 1919 his income was ten times what it had been in 1913. If his work was disparaged, as the say goes, he laughed all the way to the bank. Ed left Chicago with his pockets jingling.
Next: Part II: If Pigs Had Wings
Edgar Rice Burroughs Rides The Rocket: A Short Life
Eddie was a ramblin’ gambling’ man. He was born in a pair of ramblin’ shoes and he always took the most desperate chances. When he succeeded he was spectacular but when he failed…oh, well.
Perhaps the biggest gamble he ever took was being born but then, as Eddie always said: to me to conceive is to act. Things started out well as he began his life as a little prince but would soon turn sour when he was eight and lost a confrontation with a twelve year old bully on a street corner on the way to school. That was a life changer; he’d gone from prince to pauper and worse was yet to come. But, hey, it’s all education, isn’t it now?
The next year he began a foot race with the plague which he would ultimately lose. But as with being born he was initially successful. In an effort to escape the epidemic he was transferred to an all girls school. Apparently this was a polite plague selecting only boys. So like young Achilles Eddie took his place among the young ladies.
Still pursued, as one imagines, he was put for safety in a Latin School, one imagines as a place the fever would never look for him and if it found him would never enter the abode of such objectionable learning. Still, a young man of means he owned both a pony and a bicycle. The pony he rode back and forth to school leaving it tethered outside while he soaked up the classical knowledge. The bicycle he rode for fun but tipped over banging his head against a curb. This left him dizzy for days perhaps contributing to his later character which was formed by a similar incident.
While secure at the Harvard Latin School of Chicago for a couple years, the plague was not to be baffled forever. Eddie took to his heels running as fast as he could way out across the Western Plains to Idaho to become a Jr. cowboy. No box tops necessary.
If this picture is any indication he was quite a dude. Look at those chaps! The rowels of those spurs were so big they dragged on the ground announcing his approach from some distance. It was not all bravado however as he did have quite a way with the horses. Eddie was quite happy on the ranch and he might have become a Sr. cowboy but fate put some itchin’ powder in Eddie’s ramblin’ shoes and he resumed his ramblin’ ways. Doing an intellectual about face he and his guitar showed up at a Harvard prep school called the Phillips Academy. It was soon discovered that he didn’t know how to play guitar and hadn’t even learned any good cowboy songs such as The Streets Of Laredo, The Chisholm Trail and other titles of that ilk. Didn’t even know how to sing, either.
This disappointed the faculty, as well as his low grades, so that they couldn’t bear Eddie’s presence. Thus he was told to put his ramblin’ shoes back on and git along.
As you can tell, by this time Eddie was accumulating a fair amount of educational experience though not of the academic sort. Still of tender years and still outdistancing the plague Eddie had to find another educational emporium to fill out his youthful years. His father, actually the agent of all this agitation, for some reason thinking him a delinquent, did what all fathers of delinquent kids do, he enrolled the lad in a military academy. Supposed to make you learn to stand up straight or something like that. Yep. If the plague showed up there they’d most likely make him stand at attention until he got tired of it.
After all this ramblin’ Eddie was becoming quite a character. In addition to performing some typical goofy stunts Ed was a star rider on the Equestrian team as well captaining the football team as a quarterback. Just to put in some good words for Eddie here and raise him in your estimation, Ed led the Michigan Military Academy Tigers, or whatever they were called, to a draw against the mighty University Of Michigan Wolverines. Always an odd sobriquet I thought and in a competition between a tiger and wolverine which would you bet on.
Now, this nearly miraculous feat did not go unnoticed. He so impressed the Wolverine coach that Ed was offered a full football ride at Ann Arbor. Well, you might say, that was really wonderful. Yes, it could have been. But the imp of the perverse was down in those ramblin’ shoes as well as the itching powder as Eddie turned the coach down. If the offer had come from Yale that would have been different, but UM? Eddie had his heart set on Yale, which his brothers had attended, and it was Yale or nothing. Yale was uninterested.
That was a positive life changing experience that Eddie missed but fate was cramming the next few years with a bunch more, some of them very memorable. Plus the plague was waiting for him just around the corner. That was going to be a stunner.
First up was one of those glorious once in a lifetime experiences that only succeeds if you’re at the right age. Eddie was and he had one glorious summer in the year of ‘93. The Chicago Columbian Exposition. The promoters couldn’t get it together to open in ‘92 which would have been that actual 400th anniversary year of the intrepid navigator’s voyage but the promoters were ready in ‘93. Eddie was seventeen and spent the summer of his life at the Expo grounds.
I’m going to have to try to set the Expo up for you because in its own way it was the highpoint of Western Civilization before and since. Western confidence just began to sort of evaporate after the fair was over.
II.
Eddie In Wonderland
The nineteenth century was quite something. It was the century of magnificent discoveries and achievement. Society chooses to diminish those wonderful scientists by derogatorily calling them Dead White Men while sneeringly dismissing them. Pardon me, if I’m sentimental but those were the guys that made the present possible and I can’t admire them too much. They’ll always be my revered ancestors to me and not Dead White Men. Down with negativity.
Technology and Science just exploded as scientific research opened new and very broad vistas to human view that never would have been opened without them. The machinery was incredible. The accumulated wonders were first put on display at London’s Crystal Palace Exhibition of 1851. Six million people wandered through. It was breathtaking as the world of tomorrow went on display.
The Centennial Exposition of 1876 in Philadelphia followed as an international competition began to form. Next came the 1889 fair in Paris for which the Eiffel Tower was created to form the triumphal arch through people entered the fair. Boy, there was an eye opener. Over a thousand feet tall, 300 steps up to the first level and 300 more up to the second. Tough act to follow but out there on the very edge of civilization existed the city to do it. Chicago. Chicago itself was considered exhibition enough. The Iron Chancellor, Bismarck himself, said that his only regret was dying without ever having seen that Chicago.
By 1893 the conditions for a perfect fair had formed. Steam safely delivered hordes from across the seas and steam brought them to Chicago in long lines of Pullman cars pulled by a mighty eight wheeler. The conditions were perfect and Chicago had the men of vision to realize the perfect fair- and how! And there were men to commemorate it as it deserved. H.H. Bancroft published a large size five volume set displaying its wonders in detail
The setting on Lake Michigan was spectacular; a one of a kind creation, never since replicated or even close to it. The Century Of Progress of 1933 was but a pale imitation. If you’ve read The Devil In The White City you know a fuller description than I’m going to give here. The White City, as the fair grounds were called, was a fairy land, life as it could be. It contrasted with the Black City, life as it was, of everyday Chicago. Industrialism was a recent phenomenon in the nineteenth century so that in the giddiness of creation such things as environmental concerns and labor relations had been neglected or at least not seen in their true importance. Everyday Chicago was a grim place; Eddie often makes unflattering remarks about his home town throughout his novels. It was smelly, smoky and dirty with huge slums not to mention institutionalized crime. They’ve shut down the stockyards but the criminal mentality remains.
The White City in contrast was a city as it could be and should. L. Frank Baum would later use it as the model for his Emerald City. As there was great labor unrest in Chicago at the time the labor force was critical. Those who signed on were quarantined to the site while work was in progress so as not to be corrupted by the labor dissidents. They threw up some of the most massive buildings in existence, practically overnight. They created pleasure gardens and a whole pleasure island. They had the midway of midways, in fact the term Midway was originated at the Expo. In competition with Paris’s Eiffel Tower the worlds’ first monster Ferris Wheel was brought into existence. While in the US the Wheel was turned into a carnival ride now many European capitols display huge four hundred foot Ferris Wheels next to their Houses of Parliament. No US city does; even the original Ferris Wheel was dismantled and has disappeared into some junkyard, perhaps having been converted into the steel beams of a skyscraper.
The Expo not only featured the technological and scientific triumphs of that fabulous nineteenth century but all the intellectual advances; Francis Galton the English psychologist displayed his achievements; Frederick Jackson Turner announced his seminal work on the disappearance of the frontier; The Congress of World Religions set up its tent over in the Black City to discuss how religion was to meet the challenge of science.
One of the first of the body builders, The Great Sandow, performed his strength stunts and flexed his muscles giving Eddie the germ for his seminal literary creation a few years hence.
Imitation Zuni Cliff Dwellings were created, a whole Dahomian village was thrown up, staffed with real Dahomians brought over for the fair. Eddie was influenced by these but he really enjoyed the peep show- forty beautiful women, count ‘em, forty, on display for your delectation.
Dozens of huge buildings from nearly every State and country, art works created an instant museum to rival the great museums of the world. Just outside the gates, too late to be included within, the fabulous Buffalo Bill’s Wild West. History portrayed while it was still in making out on the Western Plains. As incredible as it may seem among the performers was no less than Sitting Bull himself, the engineer of Custer’s defeat at his Last Stand. Amazing. It’s all show biz, folks.
The White City shot up out of the beach sands and chiggers, existed for a few months and then it was gone, burned to the grounds by the labor malcontents of the Black City. Fire is the devil’s best friend. Before it was gone Eddie and his fellows from the Michigan Military Academy marched into that Sacred City like so many Greeks at Troy, in pomp and circumstance. The troops of the MMA strutted in while the band played on. It filled Eddie’s heart with pride. Five years later, slightly inebriated, he and a friend would hire a band parading along behind it through the street of downtown Denver. Let’s just say the fair entrance was one of those thrills.
The summer of ‘93 was one for Eddie to remember. In a few years automobiles would begin to fill the streets of the Black City. In the White City of ‘93 Eddie beat them to the punch driving fair patrons around in his dad’s electric Morrison. The Morrison wasn’t much in the way of self propelled vehicles, being little more than a buckboard with benches on it, but, there was no horse in front of it and Ed was behind the wheel.
There was so much at the fair that a casual weekend visit was merely the smallest of sips, a week was a swallow, two weeks perhaps a draught. Nobody could take it in, nobody, but Ed that is. He had the full three months of that glorious summer to walk the walks, cross the bridges, stroll the romantic Wooded Island to the fabulous Japanese pavilion, gape and take it all in. You’ve got to remember that in those days before movies, TV, videos and color photography bound in convenient volumes no one, or at least very few, had ever seen such things. The fair was the prototype for all the Disney Lands and Worlds now dotting the planet.
What Ed might have missed he may have spotted in a newspaper account, rushing back to the grounds to take it in. Not everyone would know how to use what he saw and experienced, Ed did. Even if it was impossible for him to understand what he saw at the time, Eddie tucked it into the back of his mind from which it emerged in dribbles into his fiction over the thirty years of his writing career.
How lucky he was to pass the Summer of ‘93 in this wonderland. Truly a life changing experience. Not the only one coming up, Eddie had a lot more awaiting him in what he described as a boring life.
3.
Life Begins To Get Serious
First up was graduation from the MMA and the year he spent as a Geology instructor there. Then at the end of the year a depression seized Ed, probably caused by his failure to get an appointment to West Point. He joined the Army anyway leaving the MMA in the lurch while asking for the worst post in the Army’s jurisdiction. He got it. He was very lucky the Army wasn’t the French Foreign Legion or they might have assigned him to a post that made hell look a luxury resort, with no way out. The Army was more considerate, they sent him to Fort Grant in Arizona which was a few degrees cooler than hell although the accommodations were not much better.
The bad news was that Ed was in the Army finding this particular life changing experience, decidedly unpleasant; the good news was that Eddie really liked the desert and the Apaches. Zane Grey beat him to the punch writing about it but Eddie read Zane’s books assiduously. Both Arizona and Southern Utah, the border was disputed at that time, formed an irresistible attraction to him and he and Emma in their later years of marriage returned to it often. Even as Eddie was sadly contemplating divorcing this woman who had stuck with him through thick and thin, he retreated to the White Mountains Apache Reservation to ponder his situation. A deep respect for the Apaches was another consequence of his abbreviated tour of duty. Abbreviated because Ed developed what the Old Timers called a ‘tobacco heart’ and Ed had his dad use his influence to get him out. When the going got tough Eddie always took off running. He remembered that street corner in Chicago.
Well there he was, nearly twenty-five years old with no directions home although he did find his way back to Chicago, a story in itself, which I’m not going to tell here, but fragments of it can be found in The Return Of The Mucker. Ed knew how to use every scrap of his experience to advantage. For a couple years Ed hopped back and forth between Chicago and Idaho where his brothers were still running the ranch where Eddie earned those gigantic spurs.
It was on one of these trips he and an old Army buddy, a member of the Might Have Seen Better Days Club of that brief Army period, hired the band in Denver. It was also in Denver that Ed showed his gambling proclivities losing the money to cover the stretch from Denver to Idaho. As the baby brother, Big Brother Harry covered his act but Ed had set a dangerous precedent.
Part of the reason for Ed’s motation at this particular stage of his life was the maturing of his relationship with future wife Emma. As girls often do, she matured faster than Eddie and hearing her biological clock ticking was ready for the altar. Time was no longer on her side. Whether she could have ever rustled Ed out of bachelorhood is a topic for some rumination if she wasn’t at the same time being courted also by a rich handsome young fellow by the name of Frank Martin. Irish; always a red flag for Eddie who had some Irish blood of his own but considered himself a full blooded English type.
Rich and Irish. Franks’ dad was a big railroad magnate. Had his own private car to hitch at the back of the train. Well, to make a long story short Frank correctly discerned Ed’s intentions of wanting to remain a bachelor yet keep Emma on his string. Ed would go away but he wouldn’t stay away. Frank sat down and thought for a while, perhaps between breakfast and lunch, and thought he had devised a way to keep Eddie away…permanently.
It was a good plan and should have worked but it didn’t. Frank had his dad hook up the private car to a New York City bound train and then invited Ed along for the ride. Our Blithe Spirit got on the train without a qualm. One should never trust the other guy in matters concerning love or money. There are some guys who take the old saying everything’s fair in love and war quite seriously. Ed was to be given the coup de grace in Toronto on the way back. The boys went to the Toronto equivalent of Chicago’s Levee for a night’s entertainment. A couple thugs approached Ed flashing a black jack of sufficient weight and criminal dexterity to kill him but the coup and the grace separated. Ed was down and bloody but he survived. He promptly went back to Chicago and married Emma to keep her out of Frank’s hands. Now it was Frankie’s turn to cry.
We know he was a sore loser and if he didn’t stalk Ed he didn’t let him out of his sight either. Thirty-four years later when Ed and Emma parted Frank’s man Patchin was sent to LA to gloat over the divorce. Even when Eddie died, Frank had preceded him, Patchin sent a mocking letter to Ed’s son.
What I’m leading up to here is not even conjecture but just a bit of imagination, but since I know more than I’m telling, a possibility. As I pointed out for the last twenty years Ed had been dodging the plague; in 1901 he turned a corner and there he was face to face Mr. Typhoid Fever. Fever shook his hand and that was it. Eddie was down and almost out. It was a terrible bout but Ed did survive or else I might be writing about Zane Grey, a decidedly stuffy creature in whom I have no interest.
It was only a little over a year since Frank had been aced out of Emma. Definitely not long enough to cool off his hot Irish temper. A man who will attempt murder once will hold a long grudge and we know that Martin never stopped thinking of Emma and Ed. It may sound far fetched and may be it is, but as Ed caught the Typhus a year or so after snagging Emma I wouldn’t be surprised to learn that Frank Martin passed a stolen bacillus on to Ed in some way. Certainly he couldn’t have him assaulted again, an accident might have been difficult, so perhaps he introduced the disease into Ed’s food in some way. Just a suspicion.
Eddie didn’t bounce back to his feet but while he convalescing a very important book to him was issued which he devoured as it appealed to his romantic soul. He would read Owen Wister’s Virginian six or seven times by 1920. If one looks at in this way Ed made several attempts to escape Chicago until he finally succeeded in 1919. If one looks at it like that, as I say, Ed fled with Emma in 1903, 1913, 1916 and 1919.
I always look for a chain of events, the reason why. Wister’s The Virginian has a terrific reputation although it is one of those classics that leaves me cold. Wister was one of Teddy Roosevelt’s buddies. The book he wrote smells like a Gent roughing it in the wilds. Perhaps the appeal to Ed. On the one hand the novel deals with the Johnson County Range War in Wyoming of which Eddie was peripherally associated when he was an Idaho cowboy in ‘91. Several of the rebels who had killed men fled Wyoming while one or two went into hiding in Idaho. Ed apparently knew one of these desperadoes so The Virginian would have had a personal interest for him.
The love story of the book concerns a rough hewn poorly educated cowboy and a school teacher much above him who he woos and wins. They then wed while for their cowboy honeymoon the hero takes his new wife out into the picturesque mountains of Wyoming.
IV.
Buttons And Bows.
A Western ranch is just a branch
Of Nowhere Junction to me.
Give me that city
Where the living’s pretty
And the girls wear finery.
Ray Evans, Buttons and Bows
From Paleface of 1948 starring Bob Hope.
I haven’t read a study on Ed that gave any attention to understanding Emma or her history and yet she was a key figure in his success while after Ed divorced her his production declined in both quantity and quality. It would seem then that whatever drove him as a writer was connected to Emma
There were striking differences between Ed and Emma. Whereas Ed was shifted not only from school to school but from Illinois to Idaho to Massachusetts and finally to Michigan, Emma continued on at Brown School to graduation giving her a much more stable outlook on life. After graduation she studied voice in Chicago becoming familiar with the higher culture while Ed was much more familiar with the lower reaches of culture. Emma would often chide Ed for his lack of culture as he preferred boxing to opera and in later life would become a devotee of professional wrestling with all its vulgar connotations.
The Hulberts, Emma’s family, considered themselves as high class people and, indeed they were. Thus when Frank Martin came calling Emma’s father, Alvin was overjoyed finding Frank a perfect match for his daughter. Alvin quite frankly despised Eddie considering him a ne’er do well and young failure. There was certainly enough evidence to support his point of view. Before the marriage, in order to encourage Frank’s attentions to his daughter, Ed was forbidden the house. And yet Emma had her heart set on Ed and would have him. Apparently her affection never wavered although her opinion of her husband varied. As it would turn out Alvin’s view of the marriage was much more correct than Emma’s. She should have listened to her papa.
As a young girl and woman the Hulberts treated Emma to the best of everything. While her heart was set on Ed, it is obvious that she dated during all those years when Ed was not in Chicago. It is important to remember that Ed was from Chicago but his youth was spent elsewhere so that he was only faintly culturally of Chicago.
Emma was a clotheshorse. As the pictures show she was used to finery. Those are not only a lot of clothes she’s wearing but fairly expensive clothes. Clothes that Ed definitely could not provide her during the first decade or so of their marriage. When he did come into his money it was his pride that Emma could buy any clothes she wanted and he was happy to have her do so.
So, Ed, his head spinning from the Toronto bashing, and woozy from his fever attack, never particularly stable anyway, conceived the notion of taking Emma to the foothills of Idaho to reenact Wister’s novel. In 1903 then, Ed packed Emma and all their belongings to catch a train to Idaho riding baggage with Emma and their dog.
We have no record as yet of what Emma may have thought of this or whether she protested vehemently being overruled by Ed’s unreasoning passion. Of course between bashing, fever and excruciating headaches anyone might be excused erratic but innocent behavior.
Perhaps she objected using an analogous argument to Ray Evans’
My bones denounce the buckboard bounce
And the cactus hurts my toes
Let’s stay here where gals keep usin’
Those silks and satins and linen that shows
And I’m all yours in buttons and bows.
If she did use such an argument she was still in the baggage car with Ed and the dog.
I’m sure the trip was wildly romantic to Ed. His dad’s battery factory was on Madison, the hobo main stem so that I’m sure Ed had discussed the hobo life with them. His 1915 novel The Return Of The Mucker would celebrate the hobo life style as well as its successor The Oakdale Affair. So there they were, he, Emma and the dog in the baggage car like three hoboes.
Look at the picture of Emma in her finery standing in the boxcar. The look on her face echoes the lyric:
Don’t bury me in this prairie
Take me where the cement grows
Let’s go back to where I’ll keep on wearin’
Those frills and flowers and buttons and bows
Rings and things and buttons and bows.
I wonder if that was what was going through her mind.
Those long skirts didn’t work well out in the brambles, Emma didn’t have any other clothes, probably wouldn’t have worn pants if available, nor was Emma entranced with the one room balloon shack Ed threw up so their stay way out there was romantic to only one of them and of short duration.
Now comes an event painful to relate. Emma in her finery is way out there feeling miserable while Ed having removed wife and possessions to the romantic wilderness has only forty dollars in his pocket with no way to earn more. He was a rambler, he was a gambler.
Ed’s brother Harry was off in Parma so he and Emma went down to the station to catch a train to visit Harry. They had to put up for the night in what passed for a hotel room above the saloon. To this point in her life Emma had never even thought of roughing it and now she was learning all about it. To compound matters Eddie kissed her goodbye just like in Frankie and Johnny and went downstairs to find a poker game. His head must really have been hurting. They could have written the song Stagger Lee about him.
Well, he started with forty dollars thinking to inflate his stake to sixty or maybe eighty dollars but fate decreed that he come away with empty pockets. The possible reward wasn’t worth the risk. He had to have been playing with sharpies who took his cash and commiserated with his hard luck.
Let me illustrate how slick it can be. I was nineteen on the California Zephyr and two would be sharpers were trying entice me into a game of poker. They were really obvious and I wasn’t biting, I’d already dealt with sharpers aboard ship and come away cleaned. But, the railroad had an employee on board who must have been an amateur magician, he knew his cards. Dressed like a hick, walking and talking like one, he bustled up with his own deck of cards, invited me to stay, probably would have given me the best hands I’d ever seen because he meant me well, but I wasn’t really interested. Anyway he cleaned those two guys out in ten minutes and bustled off the way he came. They sat there stunned.
Now, I wasn’t present at the game Ed was in but I’d be totally amazed if those boys didn’t have a good laugh and dinner at Ed’s expense. Bad luck, good luck, Ed now stood at the bottom of the stairs swallowing hard, trying to figure out just how he was going to explain their dilemma to Emma. To be short about it, this was another one of those life changing experiences for Ed. No, sir, Ed didn’t have an explanation that Emma would accept. I mean, she could have married a millionaire and here she was in a wretched so-called hotel room a thousand miles from nowhere without a dime. Think about it. What was going through her mind?
Their relationship changed right there. It was a change that Ed would never be able to overcome; I’m sure it was the primary cause for the divorce thirty years later as Emma could never forget while Ed could never get over his shame. But, Ed hung in there for now. He recorded much of this period in his novel The Girl From Ferriss’s While a romanticized view of the years between 1900 and 1922 can be found in Marcia Of The Doorstep when Ed was again in hot water for overextending himself financially in LA.
I’m sure the railroads had a bitter taste for Ed after Frank Martin and Toronto. The memory of that private car shone in Ed’s mind like a diamond, but for now he took a job on the Oregon Shortline as a yard policeman in Salt Lake City. That is until Emma rebelled at taking in boarders ordering Ed to take her back to Chicago:
Let’s move back to that big town
Where they love a gal by the cut o’ her clothes
And I’ll stand out in buttons and bows.
Ed had a garage sale or whatever they called them back then actually selling Emma’s ornately carved marriage bed for a pittance. I’m sure that left a little scar too. Then, perhaps because Emma ragged him about riding baggage he bought a couple first class tickets back to the Black City which now appeared blacker than ever, I’m sure.
Ed was now a lost boy with responsibilities. The next seven years must have been a period of the blackest despair for him. He just couldn’t get his act together. He wandered from job to job. He landed a job at Sears, Roebuck that was a good job paying three thousand dollars a year. Not bad money in those days when unskilled labor worked six twelve hour days for from five hundred to seven-fifty a year. Ed’s prospects were good. He probably could have moved up into the five to ten thousand class in a few years. He showed up at his front door saying: Honey, I quit. Emma’s reaction wasn’t recorded but I’m sure it was voluble.
And then, of course, there were the pencil sharpeners. Ed never did sell one but he did sit down and write half of A Princess Of Mars. Who would have believed it? Munsey’s Magazine to who he had submitted it asked for the other half and gave him four hundred dollars to boot. Whether Ed and Emma sensed it or not they were on their way aboard the rocket, ready to ride.
We all hope for the success of our wildest dreams but few if any of us are prepared to manage the consequences of that success. It’s not as easy as it might seem. It’s sort of like the town bum spending a dollar for a lottery ticket and getting fifty million in return. If the bum thought he knew money before he is now introduced to the real thing.
For Ed who in his conception was born a prince, made a pauper, spending decades in disappointed expectations, now realized his destiny again. Upbraided by Emma for being a poor provider he was now in a position to provide her every desire, after taking care of his first, of course. The past weighed heavy on Eddie. The difficulties of his courtship and the shame of that gambling night in Idaho had to be rectified, reversed.
It couldn’t be, of course. One’s failures can only be recognized, accepted and lived with. But in a frenzy Ed thought that by repeating the private car incident and the disastrous trip to Idaho he could wash away the stains. Thus, having established a market for his goods, most especially with the creation of his ‘meal ticket’ Tarzan, Ed did an incredible thing. Remember he still had no money in the bank, betting entirely on the come.
As with Idaho he packed up all his goods including his useless second hand car, wife and by now three kids, bought five first class tickets to San Diego and made another attempt at fleeing Chicago. First class wasn’t the same as a private car but it was pretty close so Ed hopefully erased the shame of Frank Martin’s trip to New York City and back.
Once in San Diego, which stay lasted nine months, or long enough to be born again as the New Ed, he must have lived a princely existence going through most of the ten thousand he earned that year while returning to Chicago as broke as he had been when he and Emma boarded the train in Salt Lake City. So, he tried to eliminate his shame.
Once back in the Black City, having sold his production while in San Diego, he wrote some more, sold some more and made a seamless transition from the old Ed to the reincarnated Ed.
I would imagine that part of the plan was to get Tarzan published as a book and with that money establish himself as a man of means in his old home town. Move on up to the Gold Coast.
That would seem to be a very reasonable plan from our point of view but it was not that easy. Perhaps Tarzan, which is pure fantasy of the extravagant kind went well beyond publisher’ literary expectations. No one would touch it then, even though from our perspective the story was pure gold as, indeed, it turned out to be although not for Ed. Perhaps the novel appeared to the literary taste of Ed’s day as comic books did to literary lights in the forties and fifties of the last century, something to be burned and banned, hence Ed’s success was of the bastard sort.
He finally did get his novel published in book form in 1914 but he was stripped of most of the financial benefits as it went almost directly to reprint publishers; thus his royalties were more than halved and mere pittances of what they might have been. Still, by the time royalties began to come in Ed had created a backlog of Tarzan novels so that with current production one a year would be published for about ten years.
As the profit motive didn’t seem to be activating his publisher, the Chicago firm of McClurg’s, Ed was reduced to pleading with them to print at least twenty to thirty thousand copies before a novel was sent to the reprint house. It seems incomprehensible that McClurg’s wouldn’t do so on their own but they obstinately refused to make money for themselves and hence for Ed.
Well, the records, as I’ve been told, have been destroyed so what’s to be said. Once again I suspect outside interference. McClurg’s was an Irish house; Frank Martin was Irish. McClurg’s a was semi-public company open to investors one assumes; Frank Martin had money to invest. Until a better explanation is provided I have to believe something along those lines was happening.
But, if Eddie could have lived long enough the wonders he would have seen. At one hundred he would have been a very rich man. Those successful intellectual properties just keep gaining in value. Better than stamp collecting.
While Ed appears to have been stymied at the publishing end, that enterprise was old hat, the new wonder of the authorial imagination was movies. The Big Money, to quote John Dos Passos, Thus to some extent the movies made up for what Ed was being cheated out of in publishing. The first film production of Tarzan was the industries first million grosser. Thus when Ed successfully fled Chicago in 1919 his income was ten times what it had been in 1913. If his work was disparaged, as the say goes, he laughed all the way to the bank. Ed left Chicago with his pockets jingling.
Next: Part II: If Pigs Had Wings
Edgar Rice Burroughs As A Feral Child
July 18, 2011
Edgar Rice Burroughs As A Feral Child
by
R.E. Prindle
Cronus:
Cronus married his sister Rhea, to whom the oak is sacred, But it was prophesized by Mother Earth and by his dying father Uranus, that one of his own sons would dethrone him. Every year, therefore, he swallowed the children whom Rhea bore him, first Hestia, then Demeter and Hera, then Hades, then Poseidon~ Robert Graves, The Greek Myths
I. The Father As A Cannibal Figure
Following Poseidon came Zeus. In place of Zeus Cronus was given a stone which he swallowed instead. When Zeus grew up he then castrated Cronus, replacing him.
While on the one hand an astrological myth denoting the precession of the equinoxes from one Astrological Age to another, on a psychological level the myth relates the fear of the Father that as the strength of his sons waxes his own wanes resulting in an eclipse.
Different human fathers react in different ways. Some nurture, some castrate or cannibalize their young. This is a serious problem for the son. For instance, what Tom Brokaw, a thoroughly castrated son, is pleased to call The Greatest Generation who were so enamored of their success in WW II, that they chose to emasculate a whole generation rather than surrender or even share power.
I correspond with David Adams from time to time while doing my writing from whom I sometimes receive valuable input. I had come to the conclusion that ERB’s father, George T, was a problem for ERB, especially as represented by ‘God’ in Tarzan And The Lion Man. The new year opened with Hillman publishing Dodds’ feral child collection which clicked in my mind. The week before ERBzine published my Part III, Two Peas And A Pod of the Tarzan Triumphant review. David Adams commented favorably on my comments about the Jungian Old Man archetype. He said in an email to me:
I agree with your interpretation that “characters like Tarzan and John Carter serve in the capacity of Old Man/Jekyll figures while the actual Old Man figures who are betrayers serve perhaps as Hydelike figures as represented by the father.” (David quoting me.) Those old man figures, early and late, are also cannibals who are hell-bent on eating him up while then spreading the bones across some desert for the hyenas to chew. Who was that old cannibal with the cancerous face followed by a pair of African wolves? (Jungle Tales of Kipling)
As can be seen I picked up on the Father figure but adding the cannibal detail adds the needed dimension for full comprehension.
George T. had been bothering me for some time. The love-hate relationship ERB had with him is quite obvious, but then it occurred to me that the other sons had the same relationship to their father while George T. appeared to program them all for failure- that is they not surpass him in their lifetime somewhat like Cronus of Greek mythology. He made them all dependent on him. The supplicating tone of the letters from college of sons George and Harry is all too obvious. George T. sending the boys to Yale without the means to support a position would have had the effect of emasculating them relative to their fellow students thus subordinating them.
Then on graduation he took them into his battery business. As a businessman in Chicago it wouldn’t be unreasonable to believe that George T. had some relatively influential contacts in town who might have been able to place Yale graduates advantageously but he chose to keep the boys with him and subordinate to him.
The battery factory proved dangerous for his son Harry who developed respiratory problems from the battery chemicals plus perhaps in psychological reaction to suppression by his father. He went West to join fellow Yalie, Lew Sweetser, in Idaho. Son George, who had had enough of working for his father, also fled to Idaho to join Harry and Sweetser.
None of the three knew enough about the cattle business to survive so that by 1913 when George T. had his basket pulled up all the sons were back in Chicago in various degrees of failure or, at least, lack of success. As of that date it would appear that like Cronus George T. had swallowed or cannibalized his sons.
There was a Zeus figure in the bunch who didn’t want to be swallowed and that Zeus figure was ERB. Like Zeus ERB was the youngest son. ERB developed independently of his brothers who were approximately ten years older than he. Thus when they were at Yale ERB was attending grade school.
As I pointed out in my Books, Burroughs and Religion George T. was especially rigorous in the attempt to emasculate his youngest son. His effort culminated when he sent ERB to military school. This was a form of dislocation and rejection that ERB could not bear. He tried to escape but his father sternly returned him to the Michigan Military Academy.
The effects of this were that ERB was declassed as he considered the MMA a rich kid’s reform school. Thus to some extent he was criminalized in his own mind. His reaction was also seminal in the formation of his two principal characters John Carter and Tarzan.
His hurt was so strong, his separation from his parents and home so complete that he became psychologically orphaned. His parents died to him the day he was returned to the MMA. He adopted the drunken Commandant, Charles King, as his mentor or surrogate father. While betrayed by his father ERB apparently thought he found a friend in King. In that capacity King became the model for Lt. Paul D’Arnot of the French Navy. D’Arnot was the man who tamed the feral boy that was Tarzan introducing him to civilization much as King taught Burroughs how to survive and prosper at MMA. Or Burroughs remembered it in that manner. There may also be a literary connection to D’Artagnan of Dumas’ Three Musketeers.
This makes the period between the arrival of Jane and her party and the arrival of D’Arnot in Tarzan Of The Apes of special interest. I’m not sure what the period represents in Burroughs’ own life.
As his creation Tarzan is a feral child it follows that ERB considered himself alone and on his own as a feral child himself. A romantic notion but one no less real to him. Thus just as Tarzan’s parent’s died with the baby becoming a member of an ape tribe so Burroughs began a wild and difficult period as his parents died for him.
These events occurred just as Rider Haggard was becoming famous for his great African trilogy of King Solomon’s Mines, She and Allan Quatermain which ERB undoubtedly read at this time. Conan Doyle began his Sherlock Holmes mysteries and H.M. Stanley disappeared into an unknown Congo in pursuit of Emin Pasha. The West to East transit of the Congo impressed ERB greatly as his own heroes later crossed Africa in the same direction.
Being a complex individual ERB no longer wished to even acknowledge that he had ever had parents; thus his first creation- John Carter. As Carter only came into existence when ERB was 36 the writer had plenty of time to knock around learning the odd legend here and there. John Carter then is a version of the Great Historical Bum- the hundred thousand year old man of folklore.
John Carter could not remember his parents. In his memory he had always been the same age he was. In the words of one of my famorite songs, Stewball, he didn’t say he was born at all, just blew down in a storm. Certainly Burroughs had heard of the Comte de St. Germain who flourished at the time of the French Revolution. As esoterical cult figure today, St. Germain’s legend would have been more prominent from 1875 to 1911 than today. Like Carter St. Germain claimed to have been alive forever. In Revolutionary Europe he got away with it. Calgiostro was another Revolutionary charlatan claiming mysterious antecedents who would have intrigued ERB’s imagination. It seems certain the two would have been topics of conversation in the time before radio, TV and movies so it wouldn’t have been necessary for ERB to have read anything.
I doubt if he had read any of the books on Dodds’ list although one never knows but the list goes to show that the feral child would have been a popular topic of conversation. In my opinion then ERB’s literary future was cast when his cannibal father returned him to MMA.
He graduated from the MMA in ’95 but either couldn’t or wouldn’t return home staying on as an instructor. In ’96, just before the summer break which might have necessitated a return home he joined the Army being sent directly to Arizona without passing through Chicago. Was he avoiding returning home? One can’t say as in ’97 having found Army life not to his liking he received an early discharge. He could have kept going, of course, as many of us in his boots did, to LA, San Francisco or wherever but he chose at that time to return to Chicago. Of course, Emma was calling.
From ’97 to ’03 or so he worked for his father which he found as difficult as his brothers had. Fleeing Chicago to Idaho in 1903, when he came back a year and a few months later to do anything (that word anything has some meaning in this context) rather than work with his father. He became one of the poet Robert Service’s ‘men who don’t fit in.’ He had a very difficult few years from 1905 to 1913 bumping along the bottom.
But then in 1911 he began his rise via his intellect. He began to write becoming an immediate literary success of sorts. By 1913 when he was about to become a financial success through his intellectual efforts thus escaping his father’s curse, his father died. The young Zeus thus never got to castrate his father Cronus.
One can’t know what would have happened to his psychology had ERB been able to present his father with evidence of his success. I’m reasonably certain George T. would have belittled or rejected his success as like Cronus his youngest would have replaced him. He wouldn’t have liked that.
II. A Hand From The Grave
Had that happened and ERB been able to prove himself a greater than his father it is interesting to speculate as to what effect that might have had on ERB’s psychological development. As it was, a few months after his father’s death he packed up family and belongings and got out of town as far as he could go to San Diego, California and stayed away nine months. Time enough to be reborn.
There are numerous examples of betrayers who are cannibals in his corpus, in fact there is so much betraying and cannibalism in Burroughs’ work I find it slightly offensive. Rather than work up a list, which for the time being I leave to David, I’d rather concentrate on the most spectacular cannibalistic betrayer of the oeuvre, God of Lion Man.
I know I just wrote about Lion Man but with David’s interpretation of cannibalism I can present a much more cogent image. David’s much more into Jungian synchronicity than I am but the scene with God presents a remarkable occurrence of synchronicity. The scene is very complex.
George T. was born in 1833 so the book was written on his 100th birthday. Chicago was incorporated in 1833 while it was celebrating its Century Of Progress forty years after the Columbian Expo at the same time. Both events occurred just at the time that Burroughs realized he had lost control of his ‘meal ticket’ to MGM.
MGM was undoubtedly a component of God, the Father, being combined with the Chicago that fathered him and George T., his actual father, in his mind. From these components ERB then creates the magnificent apparition of God as man and beast. God has the mind of divine power such as had Zeus but is still a Cronus, is, in fact, the ultimate cannibal.
Tarzan and Rhonda represent Burroughs’ Anima and Animus so that God has the whole man in his power in its component parts- the X and y chromosomes. God tells the pair that he is going to use them to rejuvenate himself by cannibalizing them. The Father’s desire and the Son’s fear.
If God represents George T. on one side, MGM on another and organized religion on a third then even though ERB thought he escaped his father in 1913 by his intellectual efforts the father reaches up from the grave on his 100th anniversay to claim his son again.
At this time Burroughs also wrote Pirates Of Venus and Pirate Blood. Both would refer to the idea that MGM pirated his creation from him while the very despondent Pirate Blood is almost terrifying in its manic depression as the balloon rises and sinks being almost submerged in the ocean or the waters of oblivion, the subconscious mind, insanity, that I believe we can see it as the insanity of despair. At the end of that story the hero pairs up with a desperate woman who I believe we can read as Florence. All very transparent really.
So there Tarzan/Rhonda/Burroughs is trapped in a prison. He attempts his earlier escape of rising through his intellectual powers, that is, he ascends through a shaft in the roof. Unlike the first time when he surprised and astonished the world with John Carter and Tarzan, God, the Father, is waiting for him preventing his use of his intellect. In point of fact Tarzan And The Lion Man was a dismal sales failure thought by Burroughs to be caused by MGM.
If his previous four previous Tarzans under the Burroughs imprint had been successes it seems strange that the truly excellent Tarzan And The Lion Man should have failed. Failing proof of sabotage on the part of, say, MGM, one can only say the public taste is fickle or perhaps the innovative dust jacket didn’t look like the usual Tarzan dust jacket and fans just passed it by. It is also true that the book was a put down of MGM.
Tarzan/Burroughs sallies forth from his hiding place against superior forces. He is knocked unconscious. A sure sign that Burroughs is under supreme stress. Meanwhile God’s castle, in other words the literary structure of the last twenty years is going up in flames. The MGM pirates have lifted ERB’s life work.
He has to finish the story so he turns the tables on God taking him captive and making him do his bidding. Tarzan helps God recapture his City then abandons him disappearing down the hole of the subconscious to a lower level from when he emerges to be claimed by the Wild Thing- Balza, the Golden Girl, or Florence.
In a thinly disguised scene Tarzan, unwittingly it seems, wins Balza from her former husband much as Burroughs took Florence from Ashton Dearholt. The important thing here is that a transition has been effected from one world to another. The intellectual City of God has been abandoned in favor of a world of the senses.
It is at this point ERB abandons his own feral boy persona of horses, puttees and other symbols to become a sort of effeminate Dandy. He now affects tightly fitted fashionable suits almost effeminate in appearance. He turn into a party animal and if he had been a moderate drinker during his teens, twenties and early thirthies he now becomes almost a lush.
So, in the end, ERB was probably devoured by the Father in Cronus fashion. In the Myth Zeus forced Cronus to vomit up his brothers and sisters and he castrated him. In real life ERB was castrated and swallowed down.
He put up one heck of a fight that arouses the warmest admiration of him. One wonders, that if when all is said and done anyone can escape the imprint of those formative years. Is one’s whole horoscope cast in the womb and those few short months after birth? Sure hope not.
Part I, Prologue: A Review of Trilby, The Martian, Peter Ibbetson of George Du Maurier
April 27, 2009
A Review
The Novels Of George Du Maurier
Peter Ibbetson, Trilby, The Martian
Part I
Introduction
by
R.E. Prindle
Contents:
Part I: Introduction
Part II: Review of Trilby
Part III: Review of The Martian
Part: IV: Review of Peter Ibbetson
Occasionally a book finds it way to your hand that seems as if the author had you in mind personally when he wrote it. This one’s for you, Ron. It is as though his mind is communicating directly with yours over perhaps centuries. A couple two or three decades ago one such work that came to my hand was The Secret Memoirs Of The Duc De Roquelaure. I never would have bought it myself, never even suspected its existence, but it came in a bundle of books I bid on at auction containing another book I wanted.
I had the four volumes of the Duc’s life so I read them. The memoirs were ‘Written by himself now for the first time completely translated into English in four volumes.’ Thus in 1896-97 an intermediary on the same wave length as the Duc and myself provided the means for me to read the Duc’s mind. Believe it or not the edition was limited to 1000 copies, privately printed of which 500 were for England and 500 for America. Mine is number 424 of the English set.
There could have been few who had ever read the Duc and I may very well be the only man alive at the present to have shared the Duc’s thoughts. Truly I believed he was speaking directly to me over the 400 intervening years.
I had the same feeling when I read George Du Maurier’s three volumes published from 1891 to 1897. Curious that the Duc de Roquelaure should have been translated in 1896-97 isn’t it? Like the Duc George Du Maurier seemed to speak out to me over more than a hundred years to communicate directly with my mind.
I probably never would have sought out his books except for my Edgar Rice Burroughs studies. I wanted to check out whether there may have been a connection to Burroughs through the second of the novels- Trilby. Then browsing the store I came across a Modern Library 1929 edition of the first of Du Maurier’s efforts- Peter Ibbetson. At that point, I thought, I might as well get the third- The Martian- which I did. This time over the internet.
I have now read each title three times as is my habit if I’m going to review a book. Before moving on to the novels it might be appropriate to say a few words about Du Maurier who may be an unfamiliar name to the reader although he or she may be familiar with the name of his very famous creation, the hypnotist and musician Svengali of the Trilby novel.
Du Maurier was born in 1834 and died in 1896 so he was ideally situated to view the whole Victorian era. Indeed, in his own way he was a symbol of it. As a most famous illustrator of books and an artist satirizing the era for the humorous magazine Punch, he in many ways interpreted English society for itself for nearly fifty years.
He died of heart disease so when he turned to writing to begin what is his virtual literary epitaph in 1891 it may have been with the premonition of his imminent death. He sensed that it was time for a summing up of the life he loved so well. Heart ailments figure prominently in his work. Indeed he died of a heart attack just after finishing The Martian which began publication shortly after his death. Thus while portraying the scenes of his life in Punch and other magazines and books he summarized his life and times magnificently in his three novels.
They are magnificent works. As every man should Du Maurier loved his life and it was a life worth living. The novels are wonderful examinations of exotic altered states of consciousness. In Peter Ibbetson the protagonist is insane, committed to Colney Hatch or some such. At night in his dreams he finds a way to link his dream with the dream of a married woman on the outside. She and his dreams meld into one dream in which they live actual alternate dream lives that are as real as their daytime existences. This went on for a couple decades or more until the lady died. Very eerie.
In Trilby in a love contest between the protagonist Billy and the musician Svengali for the hand of Trilby Billy is denied his love for societal reasons while after a sequence of events Trilby falls into the clutches of Svengali who through hypnotism turns her into a Diva. After his denial Billy becomes temporarily deranged falling into a deep depression which then turns into an equally severe melancholia when he emerges from the mania. So once again we have a description of two altered states of consciousness.
In the third and last novel the protagonist is possessed by an alien intelligence named Martia from Mars. Over the last century she has inhabited thousands of people but only with the hero, Barty Josselin, has she been able to establish contact. In an absolutely astonishing twist she occupies the body of Barty’s daughter. Both Barty and the daughter die enabling Martia to unite pshysically, in the spirit world, with her love. Thus the father and daughter are united which I suppose is the dream of many a father and daughter. The effect on the reader, this one anyway, is ethereal and eerie.
Du Maurier injects real life figures into his fiction. The real personalities of the day lend credibility to the fiction. Du Maurier involves himself in the stories in ingenious ways. While one can’t definitely say that Burroughs learned to inject himself into his stories from Du Maurier yet the framing devices in which Burroughs plays himself are very reminiscent of Du Maurier.
For instance in the Martian the story is a biography of Barty Josselin told by his friend Robert Maurice who then asks George Du Maurier the famous Punch illustrator to illustrate and edit his book. So the biography is ostensibly told in the first person by the fictional Robert Maurice while it is illustrated by the real life George Du Maurier who posing as the editor is actually writing the book. Du Maurier even inserts a long letter of acceptance in which he recapitulates his memories of Barty.
When one realized this the effect is almost supernatural, especially as with a little background on Du Maurier one realizes that the histories of the protagonists are virtually fictionalized histories of Du Maurier himself.
Thus while I haven’t discovered a direct connection to Du Maurier ERB is always telling a fictionalized account of his mental states along with a virtual chronicle of his life. A few points in ERB’s The Eternal Lover bear a very close resemblance to the love themes of Du Maurier especially in Peter Ibbetson and The Martian.
The Martian itself may have been a major influence on Burroughs’ own Martian novels. When John Carter, who was always attracted to Mars,stands naked on a cliff face in Arizona with his arms outstretched toward the Warrior Planet the scene is very reminiscent of Barty Josselin leaning with out stretched arms from his window staring at Mars and imploring Martia for her assistance.
Carter is magically transported to Mars in some unexplained way that may have been no more than an altered state of consciousness much as in the same way Martia inhabited Barty’s mind and body. Once on Mars Carter finds his lady love, Dejah Thoris, in a manner reminiscent of Barty and Martia. Obviously other literary influences abound in ERB’s Martian series but at the core very probably is Du Maurier’s story of Martia and Barty. By 1911 the influence was coming from ERB’s subconscious and he may not have been aware of the resource he was drawing on.
The question is when did Burroughs read, as I believe he did, the three Du Maurier novels? As ERB’s first novel, A Princess Of Mars, had to be built on the Martian it follows that ERB read Du Maurier before 1911. Du Maurier wrote from 1891 to 1896. His novels were serialized in Harper’s Magazine in the US either before or at publication so Burroughs had the opportunity to read them in magazine format as well as the books.
Of the three novels, Trilby was an absolute smash being one of the biggest sellers of the nineteenth century. The sensational story of Trilby and Svengali that everyone concentrated on would certainly have brought Du Maurier to ERB’s attention.
At the time his own life was in turmoil. At the time Trilby was published ERB was in the process of leaving the Michigan Military Academy at which he was employed for what he thought was a career in the Army. Once at his assignment, Fort Grant in Arizona, he would likely have had the odd idle moment to either read the magazine installments or the book.
As Carter’s transfer to Mars takes place in Arizona there is an association with ERB’s army days and Du Maurier’s The Martian. Not proof positive, of course, but not impossible or improbable either. He must then have read the last volume in Idaho when he owned his stationery store there in 1898 and could obtain any book or magazine he wanted, either English or American.
So these wonderful other worldly stories of Du Maurier gestated in his mind for twelve or thirteen years before emerging from his forehead beginning in 1911.
I will now review the novels in detail. These are spectacular, wonderful stories. First the middle volume- Trilby- then the last of Du Maurier’s works- The Martian- followed by the first, Peter Ibbetson.
The review of Trilby is Part II, call that up.